Gonna give you credit - good comparison. Again, I said "borderline" I didn't say sure thing.
I just thing you guys are disrespecting Culpepper too much, the same thing I say to you guys about McNabb.
Schaub's had a damn good career. He has nothing to apologize for.
Why the fuck do you say this about every NFL player. You said Rex Grossman has nothing to apologize for, for fucks sake.
dave seems to equate not being a HOF'er to being a worthless POS.
It's the highest standard we have to rate a player, it's not an insult to say these guys come up short. Not every (really) good player is HOF worthy, and that's OK. I think all HOF's put in far too many players.
I read thread, immediately lol'd. Jumped in and voted no. Saw the stats posted and lol'd some more. Total fucking joke anyone who votes yes with Dave on this needs to leave the boards immediately don't pass go, don't collect 200 dollars.
If Culpepper could've continued at that pace before blowing his knee out I think he may have had a case right now. But that can be said about a number of guys in the NFL, injuries and cut short careers cannot be ignored.